01.19.14

Minecraft, and Why I Think The Kids Are Alright

Posted in Blog, Homeschooling, Uncategorized at 6:59 pm by Robin Stevenson

IMG_0010

In the last few weeks, I have had several encounters with people who have expressed strong disapproval of the game Minecraft, seeing it as somehow harmful to their children– or at the very least, as a mindless distraction from more important things.  I disagree. Full disclosure: Minecraft has been a huge part of my life, courtesy of my son, for two years. I play the game with him. We went to Minecon 2013. I jokingly refer to our approach to home learning as the Minecraft Curriculum.

And, um, our cat is called Mojang… after the makers of Minecraft.

mojang

 

So what’s going on? Why are kids so into Minecraft, and why is it such a source of parental anxiety?

At a party a few weeks ago, a parent of another boy told me that she had “very strict time limits” for her son’s “screen time”.  Screen time is a really unhelpful expression.  It could refer to watching cartoons, playing a game online, practicing typing, writing a novel, sharing a family movie night, learning trigonometry on Khan Academy, reading a book, looking up a history fact on Wikipedia, or Skyping with a friend. Why lump all these diverse activities together? Let’s pay attention to what our kids are actually doing.”

A middle-school teacher recently told me that a number of parents had said that their kids were “obsessed” with Minecraft or “addicted” to the game. These words carry a huge amount of judgement and fuel parental anxiety. But come on: Minecraft is not a drug and most avid Minecraft players are not addicted. They might miss it if they couldn’t play, but I doubt they would have withdrawal symptoms.  And as for obsessed, why can’t we just say that they love to play it? That they enjoy thinking and talking about it? That they want to get better at it? After all, if a kid loves dinosaurs, math or violin, we call it a passion.

IMG_0035

Another mom recently shared her worry about her son “thinking too much” about the game.  But I think this can be because it is a hugely complex game with many layers and great potential for learning. Thinking is a good thing, right? It’s not a problem. Kids learn through play, and computer games have real benefits.

Over the past two years, I have seen unbelievable learning come from my son’s involvement with Minecraft: learning how to get mods, host a server, down-load plug-ins and make mini-games; creating adventure maps with attention to aesthetics and story lines; developing an interest in modding and coding in java; starting a YouTube channel; making and editing videos; learning about digital animation; making websites…  the list could go on for pages. The learning is broader than computer skills: My son has developed skills in searching for information online, speed reading, fast typing and accurate spelling- all through play, which is, after all, how kids learn best. Perhaps most importantly, the game encourages creative thinking and problem-solving. The persistence and determination that I have seen kids show in trying to to understand and resolve a complex issue in the game is impressive.

Minecraft is always changing and growing, largely part to the enthusiastic and madly creative community that the game has given rise to. There are mods for kids who love interior design, kids who love horses, kids who like explosions, kids who like dirt bikes, and kids who like Dr. Who.  There’s even a quantum physics mod.

IMG_0011

A friend whose son just started playing joked that she wonders when she’ll she him again. It is true that the game can be consuming! But here’s my suggestion: Get your own account. Play the game. Seriously, embrace your kid’s interest and join him right there. Play together. If you don’t like battling monsters, then build cool stuff together. Or play on one of the Minecraft minigame servers—my son found one a few days ago that I loved: a Minecraft version of Pictionary! Find cool links, watch YouTube videos together, listen with real interest when your kid shows you what he has made. Minecraft won’t gobble up your kid.

IMG_0044

Another parent, after I mentioned how much fun my son was having with Minecraft, asked, “Don’t you think he should be playing with friends?” But for my son, Minecraft has led to many new friendships. A shared passion is a great foundation for a relationship to grow on.  Minecraft has provided hours of cooperative play and many opportunities to deal with conflict and negotiate shared projects.

As I type this, I am listening to my nine year old and two of his friends Skyping together while navigating an adventure map. In a couple of days, we’re hosting a Minecraft party and the living room will be full of kids happily playing together. Yes, kids should play– and they are. It has brought my son–and our whole family– many  hours of great enjoyment.

IMG_0019

3 Comments

  1. Rachelle W (@inspiritedmama) said,

    January 20, 2014 at 11:34 am

    Thank you SO much for this, really.

    Last week I battled a few days of anxiety related to my lack of “screen time restrictions”. So long as chores are done I don’t really have any other limitations on when/how long Minime is allowed to play Minecraft. Sometimes, she’s spent an entire Saturday playing. And periodically, like last week, I feel as though I am somehow failing her because of that. Maybe to be a “good mom” I should put more computer rules in place.

    It’s nice to know I’m not alone in supporting her Minecraft habit, afterall I’m the one responsible for it! She got hooked after watching me play (proud member since early Alpha!), and for Christmas we bought ourselves a family server to all play on together.

    Excellent post, thank you!

  2. Robin Stevenson said,

    January 20, 2014 at 4:56 pm

    Hi Rachelle,
    So glad you enjoyed my post! Playing together as a family is awesome- we do this too- and honestly, I don’t think it’s all that different (though more fun, perhaps) than the endless hours of Monopoly I played as a kid.

    But I hear you about the “good mom” thing- there is so much judgement about mothering and so many different views about what good parenting looks like. I guess I try to unpack what being a “good mom” it means to me– ie. what kind of parent do I want to be, what kind of support does my kid need, what kind of relationship do I want us to have– and to make decisions based on that, rather than on some abstract idea of what a “good parents” do.

    Anyway, thanks for reading, and happy Minecrafting :)

  3. Lisa Wilson said,

    February 23, 2014 at 10:41 am

    Great post Robin! Could not agree more :-) The Minecraft journey in our home has been fascinating to watch over the years.
    It has been an avenue of expression for our boys. Our oldest is into ancient Roman times, so he builds Roman inspired buildings and armour on Minecraft. My son thinks about what it would be like to be a Roman legionnaire, he writes stories based in ancient Rome, he talks endlessly to me about Romans. Therefore, one might argue that my eldest is “addicted” to Roman history ;-) (however, I am on the same page as Dr. Gray, seeing it as a passion not “addiction”). He did the SAME thing two years ago when he started Minecraft, everything that came out of his mouth was about this game :-)
    These passions have changed from trucks when he was 2, to dinosaurs when he was 4 and so on. Now the boys have Minecraft as a place to explore their interests. And as my son said, while overhearing this conversation, “it is fun!”